Saturday, 14 May 2011
-
Teachers vs. Parents

There are individuals who, throughout the day, experience extreme levels of pressure in their Stress Tank, but manage to keep their tank from exploding until the school day is over and they get home.
It’s also common for these individuals to have strong reactions during the day that go unnoticed by teachers and peers. For example, it might look like they are listening and paying attention when, in fact, they have completely shut down their system. Or they might lock themselves in the bathroom during recess – just to get away for a while – without anyone noticing.
For these individuals, a long day, full of demands and expectations, can cost a lot of energy and often comes with a price. It can be compared with how most of us would feel after the first day at a new job. Can you imagine feeling like that every day?
Furthermore, the communication between parents and teachers can become problematic and challenging when they see two different pictures of how things are going.
The following is an example of that.
How is Ellen doing?
Ellen is doing well in school. She is ambitious and focused and gets good results on all her tests. Ellen has ADHD and Tourette syndrome, but her teachers barely acknowledge that. They think just about anyone gets some sort of diagnose these days.
Although Ellen is behaving well, her teachers has had a few complaints about her parents. Ellen’s homework usually doesn’t get done. And who is responsible for making sure that her homework gets done? Her parents are! Ellen is also absent from school on a regular basis. They estimated that she is absent about 20% of the time, and for some reason she usually misses Wednesdays. And who is responsible for making sure that Ellen shows up to school? Her parents are!
The school principal schedules a meeting with Ellen’s parents to emphasize their responsibility for Ellen’s education.
Ellen’s mom attends the meeting and Ellen’s teacher starts by expressing how well Ellen is doing in school and how good she is behaving. Ellen’s mom quickly responds, “I know Ellen is behaving in school but…” And she goes on to tell her side of the story.
Ellen’s mom tells them how when Ellen comes home after a long day of school, she throws her bag in the hallway, runs to the bathroom, and locks the door behind her. In the bathroom, she releases all the pressure that has been built up during the day. She no longer has to worry about what people think, and she doesn’t have to hide her tics. She comes out after half an hour with messy hair, completely exhausted. On good days she at least brings a sandwich to her room before locking the door behind her to watch episode upon episode of Buffy The Vampire Slayer. Sometimes she’ll come out to yell, scream, and fight with her brothers. She has no energy for extracurricular activities and rarely hangs out with friends.
What parent can then successfully knock on her door and say, “Ellen, it’s time for you to do your homework”? After a few days of school, Ellen is often so exhausted that there is no way of getting her out of bed.
“What am I supposed to do then? I can’t carry her to school!” says Ellen’s mom.
Home problem or school problem?
Is this a home problem or a school problem?
It’s without doubt a school problem. And the situation is so serious that if allowed to continue, Ellen might not make it to school at all in the near future.
So what needs to be done?
To improve the situation and ensure Ellen's future success, a balance between her energy “takers” and "givers” needs to be created and upheld throughout her school day. With the help of visual support, Ellen’s teachers and parents need to have conversations with her to assess what activities, places, and individuals give or take mental energy in her life.
Post a Comment
- Back to autisable's Autisable Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in autisable's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)

Recommend


Comments (6)
I disagree that the school has the problem. Blaming anybody doesn't help the situation. People can go as far to say why didn't Ellen's mum abort this "defect" girl in the first place.
If Ellen doesn't do homework then she doesn't. The world isn't going to end. One less homework to correct in my opinion. If Ellen doesn't go to school, then she doesn't. I'm sure the class is easier to manage without her anyway.
Why do you think the school wants her to do homework and come to school? Why would they go through the trouble of making a meeting and wasting their time? To torture Ellen and the mum? I don't think so.
Education is important for Ellen to do well in life. She has a bad set of cards to start off with already in life, she needs do "twice" as much to catch up. Obviously if Ellen is "good" at school, then that means what the teacher is doing works, the question is, what is mum doing that isn't working? Just reading this post, I see...TV in bedroom, bringing a sandwich to Ellen...seems like Ellen needs some tough love approach. If Ellen doesn't eat in the dining room, she doesn't eat at all. If there is a TV in the bedroom then why would she go out of her room to socialise with her siblings? Everything is served on a platter.
AND speaking of the tv, why does she have time to watch tv instead of doing her homework. Work first, play later.
If Ellen's mum is not happy with school, has home schooling been considered or Special education?
The goal of the school is to provide a free and appropriate education (FAPE) and they CANNOT do that effectively if Ellen doesn't do her homework, have good behavior, and show up for school. It is the parent's responsibility to work with the school to put support in place so that a student like Ellen can be successful without falling apart.
As a teacher myself I must say that requiring the school to shape itself around one person would not be the answer. I, personally, do not have the time to have special consideration for all my students, and they all have some kind of special consideration that could be minded to make their experience better. If I drop what I am doing in order to deal with one student's personal crisis every class then that is one more (or sometimes 2 or 3 more) things that I cannot teach the rest of the class because I am taking the time to deal with one situation.
On the other hand, heavily revising a lesson to suit each student's needs in the class also requires me as a teach to work several more hours a week that I do not get paid for. Which I am not going to do. I like to be sensitive to my students but I am not going to put in 5-10 extra hours a week in order to do this. I am not a counselor or a therapist.
Yoru,
WOW I am appalled a your response her especially as you are a teacher. I also am extremely glad that you are not MY sons teacher. Children with a IEP and disability have the legal right to have modified lessons and it IS your job to do so. You seriously need to re-evaluate and educate yourself on special needs children if you are going continue to teach.
what are they expecting from her that drives her so absolutely mad?
Poor kiddo.
Maybe she needs home schooling?
I had the pleasure of observing for 30 hours a Kindergarten classroom. Let me tell you, I DONT KNOW HOW THE TEACHER DOES IT?! Most of them are calm and dont need "special" attention but there are a good 5 out of 22 students that suck the energy out of the teacher. Some of them I can (guess) that they will be in special education or need special tutoring to be able to "survive" Early Childhood Education. This one boy is so sweet but he cant decote letters into forming words. Another had behavior problems. There is also a hyperactive boy and a girl who just needs to be told everything to get work done. I was able to take the pressure off of the teacher by working with kids at their table while she was able to pull kids up for individual attention. I will definetly want an aid in my classroom when I become a teacher. They are a Godsend if the school can afford it.